You can right click any note definition and click analyze. When that comes up there is a "recipients" tab. For players who don't get the badge it gives a reason. You can make adjustments to the definition based on this or alternatively you can make your own badges from scratch
NoteCaddy Manual | Coaching Packs | Blog
NoteCaddy experts: a.k.aAlso, Catalyst_Kh, Derders, karstenkloss, scoobediah (NoteCaddy Edge)