ERROR with calculating Spit Showdown Hand!!!

[Olaf]

HM show -80$ in split hand Showdown..... You can see this result over Replayer screen.

http://img205.imageshack.us/img205/7619/hm1ed.jpg

HH:

***** Hand History for Game 511716108592 ***** (On Game)
$100.00 USD NL Texas Hold'em - Friday, December 18, 09:55:00 ET 2009
Table Austin (Real Money)
Seat 3 is the button
Seat 3: potamos13 ( $80.40 USD )
Seat 5: andre soares ( $104.10 USD )
Seat 6: asciih3ro ( $95.00 USD )
Seat 7: seahawks100 ( $15.65 USD )
Seat 8: s0923064 ( $150.20 USD )
andre soares posts small blind [$0.50 USD].
asciih3ro posts big blind [$1.00 USD].
** Dealing down cards **
seahawks100 raises [$2.00 USD]
s0923064 calls [$2.00 USD]
potamos13 calls [$2.00 USD]
andre soares calls [$1.50 USD]
asciih3ro calls [$1.00 USD]
** Dealing Flop ** [ Ad, 3d, 6h ]
andre soares checks
asciih3ro bets [$7.50 USD]
seahawks100 calls [$7.50 USD]
s0923064 folds
potamos13 calls [$7.50 USD]
andre soares folds
** Dealing Turn ** [ 6d ]
asciih3ro bets [$20.00 USD]
seahawks100 calls [$6.15 USD]
potamos13 calls [$20.00 USD]
** Dealing River ** [ As ]
asciih3ro bets [$65.50 USD]
potamos13 calls [$50.90 USD]
potamos13 wins $88.75 USD from main pot
potamos13 shows [Ah, 8h ]
asciih3ro shows [Ts, Ac ]
seahawks100 shows [3s, Qd ]
asciih3ro wins $14.60 USD

The End.

[fozzy71]

Which version of HM? Is this a Run It Twice hand on FTP?

Please send us the original hand file.

Please zip and email the problem hand histories, with a link to this thread, to support@holdemmanager.net

[Olaf]

Version - Last beta 1.10.06

Ongame.

Sent on email.

[nlrob131]

I had a similiar problem and was wondering if the problem was fixed. After the flop, I was all in for about $40, one other player called and had about $5 left and the last had us both covered and called as well. I had a set, the second player pocket AA, unimproved, and the third a flush draw. The replay correctly identifed my win % as 68% which is about EV $80 of the three-way pot.

The turn went check-check with the two others and the river brought the flush card and the player who had everyone covered bet $9 which the second player called all in (about $4).

In the EV graph and the EV $ Diff, however, the hand is treated as having 0 equity (i.e. the EV $ Diff is 0.00). I've had similar issues with PT3 and know their EV graph is inaccurate, but was wondering if by chance any fixes were forthcoming or are split pots just beyond the current capacity of the software. Thanks--NLRob

[netsrak]

Our latest release is 1.10.03b/c: http://forums.holdemmanager.com/releases/23748-1-10-03c-official-release.html

[nlrob131]

Thanks for the reply. I downloaded and installed the update from your link and deleted and re-imported the hand history in question. There is still an EV error. Eventhough I was 68% to win the hand the EV $ diff is $0.00. Oddly the database notes that I am all in on the flop but under equity there is no entry, it's just blank.

[fozzy71]

Please zip and email the problem hand histories, with a link to this thread, to support@holdemmanager.com

[Patvs]

Rob... The EV was 0, because at the moment you went ALLIN (with a set of 44 on the flop) HoldemManager didn't know yet what the cards were of the other players (who continued the betting on later streets)

This scenario is different, than when two (or more) players go allin and ALL of their holecards are exposed. Some say this is a "flaw" in the current EV calculation. It's not... It's just very difficult (and actually unfair) to recontruct the EV AFTER the hand. However, I expect a different EV calculation (EV per street) will be added to HM in the future.