Had a few notes with badges created where the badges weren't showing where it seemed they should. After doing an analysis on the note definition I found a few players that had the correct success % and sufficient number of instances but the badge did not appear (no check in the checkbox) and there was no reason given as to why the badge wasn't showing. That field in the definition analysis was simply blank.
It turns out I had a mistake in my note definition. I usually open an existing note and then use the "Save New" menu item so that I can save some time since all my definitions share certain similarities. When I did that I used a note that had a value set for "strength vs average" in the Advanced tab that I forgot to change to zero. These notes in question didn't go to showdown on success so there was no way to determine strength.
Shouldn't the definition analysis show a reason of "strength vs average not in range" or cannot be determined? It would have saved me some head scratching caused by my mistake.