Player results gets messed up if i manually change buyin and rake of husngs

[rehlbe]

Hi this is my problem: on ongame.it we have hand histories that have only the total buyin, so hm has to guess (and sadly guesses wrong) the rake and payout and if i want to fix the problem selecting more than one husng at time using shift+right click from the results menu everything works fine for the selected user, but it gets all messed up for the opponent

i've tried using the default torney buyin option but it doesn't work, i think because of the hand history problem of ongame.it network

for example, i select 3 husngs from the results menu, i right click and change buyin, rake and payout.. if then i select one of the player i've played against and go check their results it displays all the stats correctly exept from the winnings, since it always consider the player to have won the prizepool whatever the finish position

Click for large view - Uploaded with Skitch

[Patvs]

Are you importing these SNG into 1.11.05e?

Email us a handhistory to support@holdemmanager.com
with a link to this thread

[rehlbe]

yes i have hm 1.11.05e, email sent

i don't know if it makes any difference but i'm running hm on a virtual machine (winxp sp3) using parallels (latest version) on a macbook with mac os 10.6.5 and postgresql 8.4 for mac

[rehlbe]

in case i didn't explain the problem properly due to my bad english this is what happens:

i import my hand histories, i play 92,2+7,8 husng on ongame.it, but hm thinks for some reason they are 90,91+9,09

Click for large view - Uploaded with Skitch

i'll take number 57 as example, which i won against "giaggi78"

after hm imports the hhs i usually select all the new games and right click to modify buyin, rake and payout like this:

Click for large view - Uploaded with Skitch

after i've modified the data in my results page everything looks fine, EV calculation is adjusted to the new buyin and payout:

Click for large view - Uploaded with Skitch

but if i go to check "giaggi78" results this is what i see:


Click for large view - Uploaded with Skitch

all matches have correct buyin and rake if i go check, but the matches he won all have the wrong payout, matches he lost have the correct payout even if payout should be 0 (and obv all ev calculations are wrong as well)

if you need furthers informations i'll be glad to help...

one last thing, if i double click on a single husng and modify all the data from the window that is opened results appear correct for me, for my opponents matches he lost have correct payout 0, matches he won have the wrong payout (181,82 instead of 184,4)

[netsrak]

Please send this as addition to your original mail - there its easier to follow.
If you already received a reply mail reply to this mail again.

[rehlbe]

Hello,

I have duplicated this problem and will forward it to the support manager to be assigned a priority and given to a programmer.


Regards,

fozzy@holdemmanager.net

this is the reply i received on January 15th, almost 5 months have passed but the problem is still there

[Patvs]

Recap:

1. The buyin info from Ongame is wrongly detected.
2. When you change the buyin info, it will screw up the EV Won (EV Won will always match the new $Won
3. If you select a different player who also played that game, his results will still show the wrong buyin in.


Issue 1/2 can and will not be fixed.
1> for obvious reasons: Ongame doesn't write any info to their files, where HoldemManager can detect the correct buyin info.
2> HoldemManager just doesn't have the ability to recalculate the EV (basically replaying a game from the first to last hand) after a game. It can only calculate EV during a game as the hands are imported.

3> This is something that should be fixed. If you edit the buyin info for game #12345 for the hero, if should be changed in the database table for ALL other players in game #12345 as well.

However I assume this bug has a very low priority.

[rehlbe]

actually when i change buyin info hm does not screw my EV won, it recalculates it according to the correct payout: this is not the issue as it isn't n.1 since that is obviously a ongame.it network problem

the problem is only n.3: if i manually change the buyin\rake\payout everything looks fine for me but if i select one of the opponents i've played with their data gets all messed up

i do know my english is not perfect, but i think that just by looking at the screenshots it should be pretty easy to understand what's the issue here and duplicating it should be pretty easy for anyone who puts 20 seconds of his time on it...